Worse than tip jars, it’s fast casual restaurants that present a receipt for you to sign with “optional” tips.
Before you know how long your food will take.
Before you know if it’ll be hot when it arrives.
Before you know if the cook omitted the onions as requested.
Before you know if you’ll have to hunt down your own napkins and silverware (ahem, probably plastic ware).
Before you know if you’ll have the ketchup you want.
Before you know if you’ll be wanting a second beer and having to stand in a long line to get one while your meal gets ever colder.
Before you know if you have to bus your own dishes.
What’s fast casual? It’s those restaurants where you eye the menu board while standing in line to place your order and pay the cashier before finding a seat. Sometimes you retrieve your own order when your name is called and sometimes a food runner–not a server by any means–delivers your order. Think: Panera Bread.
I’ve been to a number of fast casual, non-chain restaurants recently, many of which use Square credit card processing or a variant, and when the order taker thrusts a receipt at me to sign (or turns the iPad to have me sign), it offers suggested tips. Not a tip of 5 percent or 10 percent, which might be reasonable to reward an order taker and a food runner who do a quarter or half the work a server performs in a sit-down restaurant, but suggested tips of 15, 20, 25 percent–one place suggested a 30 percent tip! Really? Before I know anything about my dining experience beyond the description of the food (provided by a menu board) and the price? Are you kidding me?
Don’t get me wrong here. I appreciate good service, and I think most servers work hard and earn a 20 percent tip (20 percent pre-tax–I’m not gonna tip a server based on the government’s share). But someone who knows how to operate an order-taking device and maybe a bartender who knows how to pour a glass of beer from a tap? Twenty percent?
I wouldn’t be offended if the suggested tips started at 5 percent, but to even list 30 percent is a complete joke.
I’m going to start writing Yelp reviews complaining about this practice, and I’m going to start looking for the “other” button to fill in a tip more in line with 5 percent or 10 percent. But I’m going to look around first, and if it looks like I’m going to have to bus my own trash, I’m passing altogether on a tip. If I’m doing most of the work, I’m keeping the tip for myself.